Chanty

We’ve Tried Slack vs Flock For 2 Weeks. Here’s Our Team Feedback

Slack vs Flock

Team communication tool is a must have in a today’s office. But with so many products available these days, the question is “Which app is the best for my team?”.

Thanks to building Chanty – a simple, AI-powered business messenger, our team had to perform an in-depth analysis of our competitors. We’ve considered their pros and cons from a customer’s perspective and tried to come up with a better, cleaner and more user-friendly chat alternative.

We have an entire article with the results of competitors’ research, covering our feedback on various Slack alternatives. However, this time we would like to focus on two rivals: the well-known Slack and its Indian competitor Flock. Our team have dived into these tools for two weeks and we are ready to share our impressions today.

Slack vs Flock pricing (0:1)

Communication apps tend to receive some level of virality as a single customer may invite hundreds of teammates. Both Slack and Flock employ freemium business model to get the word-of-mouth effect. It means they both offer a free version of their product. If you’d like to upgrade and unlock additional features, get ready to pay $3 per user, per month for Flock Pro plan. With Slack, prepare to spend $6,67 (Slack standard plan) and $12,50 (Slack Plus plan) per user, per month.

Slack             Flock
Standard $6,67 user/month

Plus $12,50 user/month

Pro plan $3 user/month

Speaking of prices, Slack is the most expensive app out of all team communication tools we’ve analyzed so far. Flock is obviously more affordable, so this is the moment to consider when making your choice between Flock and Slack.

Let’s have a quick comparison of the features available in free version of Slack and Flock:

Slack (free) Flock (free)
Video conferencing For no more than 2 persons Up to 8 people
Screen sharing No Yes
Message history limit 10 000 messages 10 000 messages
Integrations Limit of 10 integrations
(with 800+ integrations in Slack to choose from)
Unlimited (with 40+ integrations overall in Flock)

As you can see, Flock offers more features in its free version and is less expensive when it comes to paid plans, so we are giving it its first credit for pricing.

Slack vs Flock interface (1:0)

The impression you get once you open Flock – it’s overloaded with too many icons, controls, options, features and information. The interface of the app is divided into 5(five!) bars with icons everywhere: on the top, on the left, on the right and even on the bottom. It was honestly hard to understand where should I focus first. Moreover, Flock has two search fields and two icons for ‘recent conversations’ on the same screen.

team communication tool

Flock interface

Slack was able to achieve a more simple interface while keeping rich functionality by hiding its features and multiple options behind the buttons like these:

messenger for business

Slack interface

Overall, Slack is more convenient and friendly when it comes to the user interface. You can fully focus on conversations in Slack without being distracted by too many icons around.

Slack vs Flock conversations (1:0)

Sending and receiving messages is the core functionality of every instant chat. It should be highlighted that ‘conversation with myself’ is an extremely handy feature in Slack. I can keep some private info and files there that are only available for me. However, if you are using a free version of Slack, keep in mind that your private conversations as well as any other will start to disappear from the history once you hit the 10K messages limit. Yep, the searchable message history is limited in Slack’s freemium plan.

Just a few months ago you could enjoy searching messages as deep as you want in Flock, but  they’ve changed it recently and put a 10K limit just like at Slack. Unfortunately, there are no conversations with myself which I missed badly after using this feature in Slack. There is also an obvious lack of privacy in Flock. It seems like everything you do – from creating a to-do item to uploading a file to pinning a message is instantly available to your colleagues. Transparency in communication at work is great, but there is still a need for some privacy which is unfortunately of a short supply in Flock.

Both Slack and Flock have an option to reply to any message in a channel conversation. When you use Slack, your reply creates a new thread and you can clearly see that the message was answered as well as click it through and view it in the right sidebar.

chat for teams

Threads feature in Slack

In Flock it’s also possible to write a reply, but it will appear as a new message in a conversation. You can’t really create a conversation with multiple messages in the thread. Once you hit the reply button to respond to an existing reply you are basically creating a new reply once again to the first message. This makes the whole “reply” functionality somewhat confusing in Flock.

team communication

Reply feature in Flock

Both Slack and Flock put the limit to their searchable message history in a free plan. When it comes to Slack, you can enjoy some privacy thanks to ‘conversations with yourself’, the thread feature is also well thought-through in Slack and is less confusing compared to Flock. Our team believes Slack wins the conversation battle 1:0.

Slack vs Flock video calls (0:1)

Flock offers free video calls and screen sharing for multiple participants via the preinstalled integration with Appear.in. At the same time video calls at Slack’s free account are only available for two participants with no screen sharing option. However, you can unlock this feature and enjoy video conversations with multiple teammates along with screen sharing in the paid plan.

Due to using third party integration, it takes 4 clicks to start a video conversation in Flock (opens up in a new window) while it’s a click-away in Slack (opens straight in the app). On the other hand we’ve experienced a better video quality while calling in Flock while we had no issues with audio quality both in Slack and Flock.

What fascinated me about video conversations in Flock was the augmented reality. It came with the Snapchat-like stickers for you to play with. By the way, our marketing team couldn’t help but had fun with it.

messenger for teams

Augmented reality during a video call in Flock

Although I can’t say it’s a must have feature for a business chat, it’s still fun to have. We’ve been eager to find the similar feature in Slack, but they only support emojis that you can add to the middle of the screen which honestly look kind of lame.

business chat

Using emojis during the video call at Slack

We’ve also experienced some bugs while turning camera on and off during the video conversation in Slack.

chat for business

Some bugs occurred during a video call in Slack

Note that Slack offers integrations with Appear.in as well as Google Hangouts. However, they are not pre-installed like they are in Flock. Moreover, considering the limited integrations in a free plan (ten integrations only), it’s not always easy to find a room for another third party app.

We believe Flock wins the video conversation battle as it offers more functionality in a free product version (screen sharing, multiple participants) and has the better video quality. On top of that, the funny special effects in Flocks integration Appear.in made our day.

Slack vs Flock Notifications (1:0)

Notifications are the integral part of every business chat tool. It’s crucial to be able to control your notifications not to irritate you every minute, but at the same time not to miss something important. Slack offers an in-depth control over all kinds of notifications.

tool for communication

Notification settings in Slack

Apart from these settings you also have an entire page of Notification preferences in Slack. E.g. you can set up a keyword notification (if someone types in a specific keyword you’ll get notified) for a particular channel, set up the time when you don’t want to get notified (do not disturb mode) and many more options.

team chat

Notification preferences in Slack

At the same time you have limited options when it comes to notification settings in Flock.

business messenger

There’s also an option to mute the entire channel in Flock.

tool for team communication

‘Mute a channel’ option in Flock

This is pretty much it when it comes to notification settings in Flock. Considering the in-depth customization of notifications in Slack, our team believes Slack wins this battle 1:0.

Slack vs Flock file sharing (0:1)

What instantly made me confused while using Slack was the file sharing feature. Firstly, once you’ve chosen a file to upload from your computer, you click Open and Slack opens up another window asking you to click Upload a file. That makes two steps instead of a convenient one. Secondly, you can’t upload multiple files to Slack. If you choose to upload a hundred files from your computer, you’ll have to push the Upload a file button for a hundred times (!).

It’s more simple in Flock where there’s no need to waste your time clicking the buttons. All you have to do when uploading the hundred files is to choose them on your computer and click Open. And it’s done. Considering the above, we believe Flock wins the file sharing battle.

Slack vs Flock file search (1:0)

It’s was a surprise for us to find out that there is no file search option in Flock. While you can view all the files you’ve shared with a particular contact at the right sidebar, you still can’t search for it. There’s a search field at the top, but it only allows you to explore the text messages, not the files. At the same time Slack offers search within both texts and files which is quite useful.

improve team communication

Conclusion

After taking a look at Slack and Flock from different angles, we’ve come up with a following table with the results of Slack vs Flock battle.

Slack                                 Flock                                
Interface 1 0
Conversations               1 0
Pricing 0 1
Video calls 0 1
File sharing 0 1
File search 1 0
Notifications 1 0
Total score 4 3

If you are choosing between Slack and Flock, you have to clearly define your business needs, budget and workflows. With Slack you receive a more user friendly interface, convenient conversation structure, customizable notifications and a powerful file search. On the other hand, file sharing could be a pain, video calls have a room for improvement and free Slack version comes with a more limited environment compared to Flock.

At the same time Flock is a more affordable alternative offering extra functionality in its free version along with a fun, higher quality pre-installed video calls and more comfortable file sharing compared to Slack. However, multiple user interface issues could be improved as well as file search feature could be added in Flock.

If you are still hesitating which team messenger tool to choose, we strongly recommend you to try out Chanty – simple AI-powered business messenger and a single notification center. We are well aware of the existing messengers pros and cons. We’ve considered them all while building the better business chat – Chanty. Sign up for a beta test and give us a try;)


Also published on Medium.

mm

Olga Mykhoparkina

CMO, Chanty Team Collaboration

Add comment

Get more things done, together

Join Chanty – simple AI-powered business
messenger to make your team super productive.
Unlimited message history. Free…Forever.